Former American Idol 2 Contestant: Clay Should've Won

Kimberley Caldwell, a contestant on the Clay's season of American Idol said last night live on the TV Guide channel that Clay should've won, instead of Ruben Studdard.

From the CB's OLMass:

Kimberly Caldwell (AI2) has a show about reality TV on the TV Guide Channel that she hosts with another young woman. The other day, they were talking about their favorite reality shows. They began discussing Dancing with the Stars and how Kelly Monaco won but they had a dance-off so that John O'Herley could win. Kimberly said it was like saying Clay should have won AI2 so we're going to have Ruben and Clay come back and sing again so Clay can win this time.

Some members of the Clayboard say that this was a 'joke' and that Caldwell did not actually mean that Clay should've won... anyhow.. Judge yourself.